A sunlit modern living room with a beige sofa, a low wooden coffee table, and large potted plants.

5-Star Secrets: How to Proactively Secure Glowing Reviews for Your Short-Term Rental

5-Star Reviews
Short-Term Rental Tips
Hosting Standards
Guest Experience
STR Strategy
Published

February 21, 2025

Author

Matthew Marcelissen

  • Instagram

In the competitive world of short-term rentals, positive reviews are the currency of success. A steady stream of 5-star ratings can elevate your listing's visibility, attract more bookings, and ultimately, boost your revenue.[1] But how do you consistently delight guests and earn their top praise?

The key is to move beyond a reactive approach and proactively manage the guest experience from start to finish. It’s not about hoping for good reviews, but implementing a system that makes them an almost inevitable outcome. Here are five actionable tips to take control of your reviews and build a thriving short-term rental business.

Eliminate Deferred Maintenance: The Guest Will Find It

It’s easy to let small maintenance issues slide in our own homes, but for a paying guest, these details matter. A leaky faucet, a dusty air filter, or a slow-draining tub can be minor annoyances that detract from an otherwise positive experience. Before a guest even sets foot in your property, conduct a thorough inspection and address any deferred maintenance. This includes:

  • Plumbing: Fix any leaky toilets or faucets.
  • HVAC: Ensure air filters are clean and the system is in good working order.
  • Exterior: Clean out the eaves and gutters.
  • Appliances: Backflush the hot water system and check that all appliances are functioning correctly.

Remember, if there's a weak point in your property, your guest is sure to find it. Proactive maintenance ensures a seamless and comfortable stay, setting the stage for a positive review. A spotless and well-maintained property is a key factor in earning great reviews.[2]

Addressing deferred maintenance is crucial for guest satisfaction.

Match Your Listing to Reality: Set Accurate Expectations

One of the quickest ways to disappoint a guest is to create a gap between their expectations and the reality of your property. While it's tempting to present your rental in the best possible light, accuracy is paramount.[3] Ensure your photos and descriptions are an honest representation of what guests will experience. Mismatched expectations can lead to feelings of being let down, which will undoubtedly be reflected in their review.

Regularly update your listing to reflect any changes to the property or amenities. Transparency builds trust and ensures that guests arrive with a clear and accurate picture of what to expect.[4]

A pristine and welcoming space is the first step to a 5-star review.

Master the Art of Guest Communication: A Proactive Messaging Cadence

Effective communication is the backbone of a 5-star guest experience.[5] By implementing a thoughtful messaging cadence, you can guide your guests through their entire journey, address potential issues before they escalate, and make them feel cared for every step of the way.[6] Consider setting up automated messages for the following touchpoints:

  • Booking Confirmation: Thank them for their booking and confirm their stay details.[4]
  • Pre-Arrival: Send a message with check-in instructions and any other pertinent information.[4]
  • The Day After Check-In: This is a crucial step. Check in with your guests to see how they are settling in. This gives you the opportunity to address any immediate concerns and demonstrate your attentiveness as a host.[4]
  • Pre-Checkout: Remind them of the checkout time and procedures.[4]
  • Post-Checkout: Thank them for their stay and ask for a review.[4]

This proactive communication allows you to resolve any issues during their stay, which can turn a potentially negative experience into a positive one.[6]

Proactive communication can make all the difference in the guest experience.

Don't Be Shy: Ask for a 5-Star Review

It may feel forward, but directly asking for a 5-star review can be incredibly effective. Many guests are simply unaware of how critical a 5-star rating is to a host's success on platforms like Airbnb. They may not realize that a 4-star review is considered a failing grade in the platform's algorithm.

In your post-checkout message, you can politely explain the importance of 5-star reviews for your business. You could say something like, "We hope you had a wonderful stay! As a small business, 5-star reviews are incredibly important to us. We would be so grateful if you would consider leaving us a 5-star review if you were happy with your experience." You can also leave a friendly reminder, like a fridge magnet, that subtly encourages a top rating.

A friendly and creative reminder can go a long way in securing that top rating.

Deliver Exceptional Customer Service: The Ultimate Differentiator

At its core, the short-term rental business is a hospitality business. Providing exceptional customer service is what will truly set you apart.[7] This means:

  • Responding quickly to messages.[1]
  • Being thoughtful and empathetic in your responses.[8]
  • Going the extra mile to ensure your guests have everything they need for an amazing stay.

When you consistently provide a high level of service, you are not just providing accommodation; you are creating a memorable experience.[8] This dedication to guest satisfaction is the ultimate strategy for earning those coveted 5-star reviews and building a business that thrives.

Watch the Full Video

For a deeper dive into these strategies, check out the full video on YouTube!